Open Wind Tunnel Analysis
Analyze and interpret open-wind-tunnel test data.
Choose or drop a JET11 fileJET11 .xlsm or .xlsx workbook, or JET JSON export
Aircraft preview
Load a JET11 file to display the aircraft.
Drag to rotate · wheel to zoom
Objectives
- Demonstrate Longitudinal Stability
- Assess "Pitch Up" Tendency
- Verify Neutral Point Position
- Demonstrate Directional Stability
- Determine Pitch Trim Position / Control Authority
- Determine Yaw Control Authority
Getting Started
Click here for more detailed instructions on how to build your Wind Tunnel Model.
You will need to produce 3 total Wind Tunnel models
- Basic: No control surface deflections
- Pitch Control: Pitch control surfaces deflected nominally 10 degrees Trailing Edge Up (TEU).
NOTE: The convention for elevator deflection is + for TED, but we don't want you to be confused... your elevator should be UP! - Directional Control: Rudder deflected 10 degrees Trailing Edge Left (TEL).
Making the Models
- Open your
*.ntopmodel. - Position the controls as necessary.
- Export the OML to the CAD folder:
./CAD/FILENAME.implicit - Open
MakeWindTunnelModel.ntop(which you can download HERE). - Position the Sting/ForceBalance Center at your desired CG.
- Export your model in a format readable by the PRUSA 3D-printing software:
./3D_Printing/FILENAME.stl - Here are some templates for your Prusa printing project. Pick the one that corresponds to the printer you want to use:
- Get it on the printer!
NOTE:
- Keep the wingspan ≤ 18 inches; bigger is better.
- Be sure not to put any supports inside the cavity that receives the sting mount.
Predict \(C_{M_\alpha}\) slope
For a conventional aircraft, the pitching-moment slope relates to static margin by:
\[C_{M_\alpha}=-SM\,C_{L_\alpha}\]
Where Static Margin (SM) is defined:
\[\mathrm{SM}=\frac{x_{NP}-x_{CG}}{MAC}\]
Therefore:
\[C_{M_\alpha}=-\left(\frac{x_{NP}-x_{CG}}{MAC}\right)C_{L_\alpha}\]
Enter your values from JET11 below, then run the code:
Static Margin (SMest)
CMα,est
Rule of Thumb (RoT) for \(C_{M_{AC}}\)
Estimate \(\alpha_{\mathrm{trim}}\)
NASA’s Static Longitudinal Stability, Chapter 6, particularly equations 6.1–6.2:
\[C_{M_\alpha}=\frac{dC_M}{dC_L}C_{L_\alpha}=-SM\,C_{L_\alpha}.\]
For the linearized moment model,
\[C_M=C_{M_{ac}}+C_{M_\alpha}\alpha,\]
trim requires \(C_M=0\). Therefore,
\[\alpha_{\mathrm{trim,est}}=-\frac{C_{M_{ac}}}{C_{M_\alpha}}=\boxed{\frac{C_{M_{ac}}}{SM\,C_{L_\alpha}}}.\]
Derived from the linear pitching-moment relation and the static-margin relation in Static Longitudinal Stability, Chapter 6, equations 6.1–6.2. NASA technical reference
NACA4-digit analytic profile
Maximum camber
\(C_{M_{AC},\mathrm{est}}\)
\(\alpha_{\mathrm{trim,est}}\)
NOW FOR THE FUN PART -- GATHER WIND TUNNEL DATA
1. Demonstrate Longitudinal Stability
- Place your Basic Model (no control surface deflections) on the OWT sting
- Make sure the planned CG is placed at the pivot point
- Balance it using the nuts and weights as appropriate
- Turn it on and observe the angle of attack it settles out at
Predicted trim response
Trim target: −5.00°Leveling to trim · ζ = 0.50Drag the aircraft nose up or down, then release it
Enter the observed AoA (this is your actual \(\alpha_{\mathrm{trim}}\)):
DATA PLOT
Estimated pitching moment versus angle of attack
Questions to consider:
- Is your aircraft stable at the planned CG?
- How do your predictions differ from the measured result?
- What will you have to do to fly level (~0 deg AoA)?
2. Assess Pitch Up Tendencies
- Make sure the planned CG is placed at the pivot point
- Slowly nudge the nose of the model up (using the armature outside of the airflow)
- Observe behavior
Nose-up perturbation:
Stable
Choose a nose-up perturbationDamping ratio, ζ = 0.40
Pitch Up Tendency
Choose a nose-up perturbationResponse depends on perturbation
Questions to consider:
- Is there an AoA when the model wants to pitch up uncontrollably?
- OR, does the model return to level at any AoA?
3. Verify Neutral Point Position
CG location: the aircraft station positioned directly over the balance pivot (axle).
- Set the assessed CG by sliding the model until the desired station is over the pivot.
- Rebalance the complete apparatus so its actual CG is at the pivot.
- Apply a small nose-up disturbance: returning indicates stability, holding the new attitude indicates neutral stability, and diverging indicates instability.
- Move the assessed CG progressively aft, rebalancing each time, to locate the neutral point and demonstrate the unstable region aft of it.
Expected behavior
- CG forward of NP: statically stable; the model returns toward trim.
- CG at NP: neutrally stable; the model remains near the disturbed pitch attitude.
- CG aft of NP: statically unstable; the pitch disturbance grows.
ForwardAft
Assessed CG / axleFull scale: —
JET11 neutral pointFull scale: —
Static margin — optional override
Calculated: —
Prediction
Estimated
Neutral-point stability response
Awaiting aircraft dataDrag horizontally for CG; drag the nose vertically to disturb
4. Demonstrate Directional Stability
- Rotate the model 90° about its longitudinal x-axis so the balance rotation represents yaw.
- Place the planned CG at the pivot and rebalance the complete apparatus.
- Apply a small left or right yaw disturbance to the nose, release it, and observe the response.
- A directionally stable model should return toward the airflow centerline.
Predicted directional response
Aligned with the airflowDrag the nose laterally, then release itThe top view represents the model rolled 90° about its x-axis
5. Determine Pitch Trim Position / Control Authority
- Place your next model (Pitch Control) on the open wind tunnel balance. It must have the elevator deflected UP.
- Place the planned CG at the balance pivot and rebalance the complete apparatus.
- Run the tunnel, allow the model to settle, and record the new trim angle of attack below.
- Compare the Basic Model response at 0° TED with the Pitch Control model response to assess elevator control authority.
Basic Model · 0° TED
Enter α_trim aboveAwaiting measured trim angleDrag the nose up or down, then release it
Pitch Control Model · −10° TED
Enter α_trim,deflectedTEUAwaiting measured trim angleDrag the nose up or down, then release it
6. Determine Yaw Control Authority
- Place your Directional Control model on the open wind tunnel balance. The rudder must be deflected 10° trailing edge left (TEL).
- Rotate the model 90° about its x-axis so the balance pivots in yaw, place the CG at the pivot, and rebalance the complete apparatus.
- Run the tunnel, allow the model to settle, and record the resulting trim sideslip angle below.
- Compare the Basic Model response at 0° TEL with the Directional Control model response to assess rudder control authority.
Basic Model · 0° TEL
Trim sideslip: 0.00°Awaiting disturbanceDrag the nose laterally, then release it
Directional Control Model · 10° TEL
Enter β trim,deflectedTELAwaiting measured trim sideslipDrag the nose laterally, then release it
JSON Viewer
Load a JET11 file to populate the JSON structure.